Bobbi Brown cosmetic products are great!

However and unfortunately, this eye liner was not great. The product may be good for some people, but it just wasn't what I was hoping -- I was looking for a really great eyeliner that was easy to apply. This is not easy to apply with the brush - the product is a bit lumpy and goes on unevenly. Since it came in a variety of eye-lining colors I was hoping it would be a terrific product, but for me, it was not. I use other Bobbi Brown cosmetics and they are very easy to apply and subtle. I wish I liked this product better, but unfortunately, I do not.