I have tried this eyeliner several ways to find its maximum potential

The first time I used it, it went on easily and I had a great dramatic line. By the time I was ready to put my mascara on, it had transferred to my upper eyelids. The stuff that didn't transfer, stayed on OK but it was now smeared. The next day I tried I thinner line, which stayed on much better. I also tried lining the inside of my lower lids, which looked great, but disappeared in a matter of hours. I also wear contact lenses, and have to scrape off the eyeliner every night when I take them out. Particles seem to stick to the lenses. I give it 4 stars because so far it goes on the best and does have a decent staying power. I love the brush. If it is drama and endurance you want, I would keep looking.